Reilly has had 16 concerts.

Reilly is most often considered to be Christian, Hollywood, Celtic, Irish, Comic, and Celtic Rock.

The last Reilly concert was on August 19, 2023 at Henry Maier Festival Park in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, United States. The bands that performed were: Lisa Canny / Finbar MacCarthy / The Drowsy Lads / Hermitage Green / Gaelic Storm / Shane Hennessy / Úlla / Scythian / Boxing Banjo / Skerryvore / Derek Warfield & The Young Wolfe Tones / Atlantic Wave / The Henry Girls / The Byrne Brothers / The Friel Sisters / The Coronas / Eileen Ivers / Cassie & Maggie / Wallis Bird / Doolin' / The Finns / The Diddley Idols / Tallymoore / The Gleasons / Steam Irish Quartet / Curtis Crossroads / Leahy's Luck / Reilly / Barry Dodd / Athas / Frogwater.

The songs that Reilly performs live vary, but here's the latest setlist that we have from the June 17, 2009 concert in North Lawrence, OH:

1. Holiday in New York
2. The Mixture
3. Charcoal Days and Sterling Nights
4. It's All Right to Die
5. I Don't Want What You Got (Goin' On)
6. God and Money
7. Duty Free
8. Hip Hop Thighs #17
9. Valentine's Day in Juarez
10. When Irish Eyes Are Burning
11. I Will Let You Down
12. Last Time
13. Put a Little Love in It (According to John)
14. The Boat Song (We're Getting Loaded)
15. The War on the Terror and Drugs
16. My Wasted Friends